testing.md 51.5 KB
Newer Older
1 2 3
A Guide to Testing Rails Applications
=====================================

4
This guide covers built-in mechanisms in Rails for testing your application.
5 6

After reading this guide, you will know:
7

8 9 10
* Rails testing terminology.
* How to write unit, functional, and integration tests for your application.
* Other popular testing approaches and plugins.
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Why Write Tests for your Rails Applications?
--------------------------------------------

Rails makes it super easy to write your tests. It starts by producing skeleton test code while you are creating your models and controllers.

By simply running your Rails tests you can ensure your code adheres to the desired functionality even after some major code refactoring.

Rails tests can also simulate browser requests and thus you can test your application's response without having to test it through your browser.

Introduction to Testing
-----------------------

Testing support was woven into the Rails fabric from the beginning. It wasn't an "oh! let's bolt on support for running tests because they're new and cool" epiphany. Just about every Rails application interacts heavily with a database and, as a result, your tests will need a database to interact with as well. To write efficient tests, you'll need to understand how to set up this database and populate it with sample data.

### The Test Environment

By default, every Rails application has three environments: development, test, and production. The database for each one of them is configured in `config/database.yml`.

32 33 34
A dedicated test database allows you to set up and interact with test data in isolation. This way your tests can mangle test data with confidence, without worrying about the data in the development or production databases.

Also, each environment's configuration can be modified similarly. In this case, we can modify our test environment by changing the options found in `config/environments/test.rb`.
35 36 37 38 39 40 41

### Rails Sets up for Testing from the Word Go

Rails creates a `test` folder for you as soon as you create a Rails project using `rails new` _application_name_. If you list the contents of this folder then you shall see:

```bash
$ ls -F test
P
Prem Sichanugrist 已提交
42 43
controllers/    helpers/        mailers/        test_helper.rb
fixtures/       integration/    models/
44 45
```

46
The `models` directory is meant to hold tests for your models, the `controllers` directory is meant to hold tests for your controllers and the `integration` directory is meant to hold tests that involve any number of controllers interacting. There is also a directory for testing your mailers, and helper methods which you are used within the view layer.
47 48 49 50 51 52 53

Fixtures are a way of organizing test data; they reside in the `fixtures` folder.

The `test_helper.rb` file holds the default configuration for your tests.

### The Low-Down on Fixtures

54 55
For good tests, you'll need to give some thought to setting up test data.
In Rails, you can handle this by defining and customizing fixtures.
56
You can find comprehensive documentation in the [Fixtures API documentation](http://api.rubyonrails.org/classes/ActiveRecord/FixtureSet.html).
57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65

#### What Are Fixtures?

_Fixtures_ is a fancy word for sample data. Fixtures allow you to populate your testing database with predefined data before your tests run. Fixtures are database independent written in YAML. There is one file per model.

You'll find fixtures under your `test/fixtures` directory. When you run `rails generate model` to create a new model fixture stubs will be automatically created and placed in this directory.

#### YAML

Z
Zachary Scott 已提交
66
YAML-formatted fixtures are a human-friendly way to describe your sample data. These types of fixtures have the **.yml** file extension (as in `users.yml`).
67 68 69 70

Here's a sample YAML fixture file:

```yaml
71
# lo & behold! I am a YAML comment!
72
david:
73 74 75
  name: David Heinemeier Hansson
  birthday: 1979-10-15
  profession: Systems development
76 77

steve:
78 79 80
  name: Steve Ross Kellock
  birthday: 1974-09-27
  profession: guy with keyboard
81 82
```

83
Each fixture is given a name followed by an indented list of colon-separated key/value pairs. Records are typically separated by a blank space. You can place comments in a fixture file by using the # character in the first column.
84

85 86
If you are working with [associations](/association_basics.html), you can simply
define a reference node between two different fixtures. Here's an example with
87
a `belongs_to`/`has_many` association:
88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100

```yaml
# In fixtures/categories.yml
about:
  name: About

# In fixtures/articles.yml
one:
  title: Welcome to Rails!
  body: Hello world!
  category: about
```

101 102
Notice the `category` key of the `one` article found in `fixtures/articles.yml` has a value of `about`. This tells Rails to load the category `about` found in `fixtures/categories.yml`.

103 104 105
Note: For associations to reference one another by name, you cannot specify the `id:`
 attribute on the fixtures. Rails will auto assign a primary key to be consistent between
 runs. If you manually specify an `id:` attribute, this behavior will not work. For more
106
  information on this association behavior please read the
107
  [Fixtures API documentation](http://api.rubyonrails.org/classes/ActiveRecord/FixtureSet.html).
108

109 110 111 112 113 114 115
#### ERB'in It Up

ERB allows you to embed Ruby code within templates. The YAML fixture format is pre-processed with ERB when Rails loads fixtures. This allows you to use Ruby to help you generate some sample data. For example, the following code generates a thousand users:

```erb
<% 1000.times do |n| %>
user_<%= n %>:
J
Jonathan Roes 已提交
116 117
  username: <%= "user#{n}" %>
  email: <%= "user#{n}@example.com" %>
118 119 120 121 122
<% end %>
```

#### Fixtures in Action

123
Rails by default automatically loads all fixtures from the `test/fixtures` folder for your models and controllers test. Loading involves three steps:
124 125 126 127 128

* Remove any existing data from the table corresponding to the fixture
* Load the fixture data into the table
* Dump the fixture data into a variable in case you want to access it directly

129 130
TIP: In order to remove existing data from the database, Rails tries to disable referential integrity triggers (like foreign keys and check constraints). If you are getting annoying permission errors on running tests, make sure the database user has privilege to disable these triggers in testing environment. (In PostgreSQL, just superusers can disable all triggers. Read more about PostgreSQL permissions [here](http://blog.endpoint.com/2012/10/postgres-system-triggers-error.html))

S
Steve Klabnik 已提交
131
#### Fixtures are Active Record objects
132

S
Steve Klabnik 已提交
133
Fixtures are instances of Active Record. As mentioned in point #3 above, you can access the object directly because it is automatically setup as a local variable of the test case. For example:
134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148

```ruby
# this will return the User object for the fixture named david
users(:david)

# this will return the property for david called id
users(:david).id

# one can also access methods available on the User class
email(david.girlfriend.email, david.location_tonight)
```

Unit Testing your Models
------------------------

149
In Rails, models tests are what you write to test your models.
150

151
For this guide we will be using Rails _scaffolding_. It will create the model, a migration, controller and views for the new resource in a single operation. It will also create a full test suite following Rails best practices. We will be using examples from this generated code and will be supplementing it with additional examples where necessary.
152

N
Nishant Modak 已提交
153
NOTE: For more information on Rails _scaffolding_, refer to [Getting Started with Rails](getting_started.html)
154 155 156 157

When you use `rails generate scaffold`, for a resource among other things it creates a test stub in the `test/models` folder:

```bash
158
$ bin/rails generate scaffold article title:string body:text
159
...
160 161 162
create  app/models/article.rb
create  test/models/article_test.rb
create  test/fixtures/articles.yml
163 164 165
...
```

166
The default test stub in `test/models/article_test.rb` looks like this:
167 168 169 170

```ruby
require 'test_helper'

171
class ArticleTest < ActiveSupport::TestCase
P
Prem Sichanugrist 已提交
172 173 174
  # test "the truth" do
  #   assert true
  # end
175 176 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186
end
```

A line by line examination of this file will help get you oriented to Rails testing code and terminology.

```ruby
require 'test_helper'
```

As you know by now, `test_helper.rb` specifies the default configuration to run our tests. This is included with all the tests, so any methods added to this file are available to all your tests.

```ruby
187
class ArticleTest < ActiveSupport::TestCase
188 189
```

190
The `ArticleTest` class defines a _test case_ because it inherits from `ActiveSupport::TestCase`. `ArticleTest` thus has all the methods available from `ActiveSupport::TestCase`. You'll see those methods a little later in this guide.
191

192 193
Any method defined within a class inherited from `Minitest::Test`
(which is the superclass of `ActiveSupport::TestCase`) that begins with `test_` (case sensitive) is simply called a test. So, `test_password` and `test_valid_password` are legal test names and are run automatically when the test case is run.
194

195
Rails adds a `test` method that takes a test name and a block. It generates a normal `Minitest::Unit` test with method names prefixed with `test_`. So,
196 197 198 199 200 201 202 203 204 205 206 207 208 209 210 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 218 219 220 221 222 223 224 225 226 227

```ruby
test "the truth" do
  assert true
end
```

acts as if you had written

```ruby
def test_the_truth
  assert true
end
```

only the `test` macro allows a more readable test name. You can still use regular method definitions though.

NOTE: The method name is generated by replacing spaces with underscores. The result does not need to be a valid Ruby identifier though, the name may contain punctuation characters etc. That's because in Ruby technically any string may be a method name. Odd ones need `define_method` and `send` calls, but formally there's no restriction.

```ruby
assert true
```

This line of code is called an _assertion_. An assertion is a line of code that evaluates an object (or expression) for expected results. For example, an assertion can check:

* does this value = that value?
* is this object nil?
* does this line of code throw an exception?
* is the user's password greater than 5 characters?

Every test contains one or more assertions. Only when all the assertions are successful will the test pass.

228
### Maintaining the test database schema
229

230
In order to run your tests, your test database will need to have the current structure. The test helper checks whether your test database has any pending migrations. If so, it will try to load your `db/schema.rb` or `db/structure.sql` into the test database. If migrations are still pending, an error will be raised.
231 232 233

### Running Tests

234
Running a test is as simple as invoking the file containing the test cases through `rake test` command.
235 236

```bash
237
$ bin/rake test test/models/article_test.rb
238 239
.

P
Prem Sichanugrist 已提交
240
Finished tests in 0.009262s, 107.9680 tests/s, 107.9680 assertions/s.
241

P
Prem Sichanugrist 已提交
242 243
1 tests, 1 assertions, 0 failures, 0 errors, 0 skips
```
244

A
Aaron Patterson 已提交
245
You can also run a particular test method from the test case by running the test and providing the `test method name`.
246 247

```bash
248
$ bin/rake test test/models/article_test.rb test_the_truth
249 250
.

P
Prem Sichanugrist 已提交
251 252 253
Finished tests in 0.009064s, 110.3266 tests/s, 110.3266 assertions/s.

1 tests, 1 assertions, 0 failures, 0 errors, 0 skips
254 255
```

256
This will run all test methods from the test case. Note that `test_helper.rb` is in the `test` directory, hence this directory needs to be added to the load path using the `-I` switch.
P
Prem Sichanugrist 已提交
257

258 259
The `.` (dot) above indicates a passing test. When a test fails you see an `F`; when a test throws an error you see an `E` in its place. The last line of the output is the summary.

260
To see how a test failure is reported, you can add a failing test to the `article_test.rb` test case.
261 262

```ruby
263 264 265
test "should not save article without title" do
  article = Article.new
  assert_not article.save
266 267 268 269 270 271
end
```

Let us run this newly added test.

```bash
272
$ bin/rake test test/models/article_test.rb test_should_not_save_article_without_title
273
F
P
Prem Sichanugrist 已提交
274 275

Finished tests in 0.044632s, 22.4054 tests/s, 22.4054 assertions/s.
276 277

  1) Failure:
278
test_should_not_save_article_without_title(ArticleTest) [test/models/article_test.rb:6]:
P
Prem Sichanugrist 已提交
279
Failed assertion, no message given.
280

P
Prem Sichanugrist 已提交
281
1 tests, 1 assertions, 1 failures, 0 errors, 0 skips
282 283 284 285 286
```

In the output, `F` denotes a failure. You can see the corresponding trace shown under `1)` along with the name of the failing test. The next few lines contain the stack trace followed by a message which mentions the actual value and the expected value by the assertion. The default assertion messages provide just enough information to help pinpoint the error. To make the assertion failure message more readable, every assertion provides an optional message parameter, as shown here:

```ruby
287 288 289
test "should not save article without title" do
  article = Article.new
  assert_not article.save, "Saved the article without a title"
290 291 292 293 294 295 296
end
```

Running this test shows the friendlier assertion message:

```bash
  1) Failure:
297 298
test_should_not_save_article_without_title(ArticleTest) [test/models/article_test.rb:6]:
Saved the article without a title
299 300 301 302 303
```

Now to get this test to pass we can add a model level validation for the _title_ field.

```ruby
304
class Article < ActiveRecord::Base
305
  validates :title, presence: true
306 307 308 309 310 311
end
```

Now the test should pass. Let us verify by running the test again:

```bash
312
$ bin/rake test test/models/article_test.rb test_should_not_save_article_without_title
313 314
.

P
Prem Sichanugrist 已提交
315 316 317
Finished tests in 0.047721s, 20.9551 tests/s, 20.9551 assertions/s.

1 tests, 1 assertions, 0 failures, 0 errors, 0 skips
318 319 320 321 322 323 324 325 326 327 328 329 330 331 332 333 334 335 336
```

Now, if you noticed, we first wrote a test which fails for a desired functionality, then we wrote some code which adds the functionality and finally we ensured that our test passes. This approach to software development is referred to as _Test-Driven Development_ (TDD).

TIP: Many Rails developers practice _Test-Driven Development_ (TDD). This is an excellent way to build up a test suite that exercises every part of your application. TDD is beyond the scope of this guide, but one place to start is with [15 TDD steps to create a Rails application](http://andrzejonsoftware.blogspot.com/2007/05/15-tdd-steps-to-create-rails.html).

To see how an error gets reported, here's a test containing an error:

```ruby
test "should report error" do
  # some_undefined_variable is not defined elsewhere in the test case
  some_undefined_variable
  assert true
end
```

Now you can see even more output in the console from running the tests:

```bash
337
$ bin/rake test test/models/article_test.rb test_should_report_error
338
E
P
Prem Sichanugrist 已提交
339 340

Finished tests in 0.030974s, 32.2851 tests/s, 0.0000 assertions/s.
341 342

  1) Error:
343 344 345
test_should_report_error(ArticleTest):
NameError: undefined local variable or method `some_undefined_variable' for #<ArticleTest:0x007fe32e24afe0>
    test/models/article_test.rb:10:in `block in <class:ArticleTest>'
346

P
Prem Sichanugrist 已提交
347
1 tests, 0 assertions, 0 failures, 1 errors, 0 skips
348 349 350 351 352 353
```

Notice the 'E' in the output. It denotes a test with error.

NOTE: The execution of each test method stops as soon as any error or an assertion failure is encountered, and the test suite continues with the next method. All test methods are executed in alphabetical order.

354 355
When a test fails you are presented with the corresponding backtrace. By default
Rails filters that backtrace and will only print lines relevant to your
C
Calvin Tam 已提交
356
application. This eliminates the framework noise and helps to focus on your
357 358 359 360 361
code. However there are situations when you want to see the full
backtrace. simply set the `BACKTRACE` environment variable to enable this
behavior:

```bash
362
$ BACKTRACE=1 bin/rake test test/models/article_test.rb
363 364
```

365 366 367 368
### What to Include in Your Unit Tests

Ideally, you would like to include a test for everything which could possibly break. It's a good practice to have at least one test for each of your validations and at least one test for every method in your model.

369
### Available Assertions
370 371 372

By now you've caught a glimpse of some of the assertions that are available. Assertions are the worker bees of testing. They are the ones that actually perform the checks to ensure that things are going as planned.

373
There are a bunch of different types of assertions you can use.
374
Here's an extract of the assertions you can use with [`Minitest`](https://github.com/seattlerb/minitest), the default testing library used by Rails. The `[msg]` parameter is an optional string message you can specify to make your test failure messages clearer. It's not required.
375 376 377

| Assertion                                                        | Purpose |
| ---------------------------------------------------------------- | ------- |
378
| `assert( test, [msg] )`                                          | Ensures that `test` is true.|
379
| `assert_not( test, [msg] )`                                      | Ensures that `test` is false.|
380
| `assert_equal( expected, actual, [msg] )`                        | Ensures that `expected == actual` is true.|
381
| `assert_not_equal( expected, actual, [msg] )`                    | Ensures that `expected != actual` is true.|
382
| `assert_same( expected, actual, [msg] )`                         | Ensures that `expected.equal?(actual)` is true.|
383
| `assert_not_same( expected, actual, [msg] )`                     | Ensures that `expected.equal?(actual)` is false.|
384
| `assert_nil( obj, [msg] )`                                       | Ensures that `obj.nil?` is true.|
385
| `assert_not_nil( obj, [msg] )`                                   | Ensures that `obj.nil?` is false.|
386 387
| `assert_empty( obj, [msg] )`                                     | Ensures that `obj` is `empty?`.|
| `assert_not_empty( obj, [msg] )`                                 | Ensures that `obj` is not `empty?`.|
388
| `assert_match( regexp, string, [msg] )`                          | Ensures that a string matches the regular expression.|
389
| `assert_no_match( regexp, string, [msg] )`                       | Ensures that a string doesn't match the regular expression.|
390 391
| `assert_includes( collection, obj, [msg] )`                      | Ensures that `obj` is in `collection`.|
| `assert_not_includes( collection, obj, [msg] )`                  | Ensures that `obj` is not in `collection`.|
392
| `assert_in_delta( expecting, actual, [delta], [msg] )`           | Ensures that the numbers `expected` and `actual` are within `delta` of each other.|
393
| `assert_not_in_delta( expecting, actual, [delta], [msg] )`       | Ensures that the numbers `expected` and `actual` are not within `delta` of each other.|
394
| `assert_throws( symbol, [msg] ) { block }`                       | Ensures that the given block throws the symbol.|
395
| `assert_raises( exception1, exception2, ... ) { block }`         | Ensures that the given block raises one of the given exceptions.|
396
| `assert_nothing_raised( exception1, exception2, ... ) { block }` | Ensures that the given block doesn't raise one of the given exceptions.|
397
| `assert_instance_of( class, obj, [msg] )`                        | Ensures that `obj` is an instance of `class`.|
398
| `assert_not_instance_of( class, obj, [msg] )`                    | Ensures that `obj` is not an instance of `class`.|
399
| `assert_kind_of( class, obj, [msg] )`                            | Ensures that `obj` is or descends from `class`.|
400
| `assert_not_kind_of( class, obj, [msg] )`                        | Ensures that `obj` is not an instance of `class` and is not descending from it.|
401
| `assert_respond_to( obj, symbol, [msg] )`                        | Ensures that `obj` responds to `symbol`.|
402
| `assert_not_respond_to( obj, symbol, [msg] )`                    | Ensures that `obj` does not respond to `symbol`.|
403
| `assert_operator( obj1, operator, [obj2], [msg] )`               | Ensures that `obj1.operator(obj2)` is true.|
404
| `assert_not_operator( obj1, operator, [obj2], [msg] )`           | Ensures that `obj1.operator(obj2)` is false.|
405 406
| `assert_predicate ( obj, predicate, [msg] )`                     | Ensures that `obj.predicate` is true, e.g. `assert_predicate str, :empty?`|
| `assert_not_predicate ( obj, predicate, [msg] )`                 | Ensures that `obj.predicate` is false, e.g. `assert_not_predicate str, :empty?`|
407 408 409
| `assert_send( array, [msg] )`                                    | Ensures that executing the method listed in `array[1]` on the object in `array[0]` with the parameters of `array[2 and up]` is true. This one is weird eh?|
| `flunk( [msg] )`                                                 | Ensures failure. This is useful to explicitly mark a test that isn't finished yet.|

410 411
The above are subset of assertions that minitest supports. For an exhaustive & more up-to-date list, please check [Minitest API documentation](http://docs.seattlerb.org/minitest/), specifically [`Minitest::Assertions`](http://docs.seattlerb.org/minitest/Minitest/Assertions.html)

412 413 414 415 416 417
Because of the modular nature of the testing framework, it is possible to create your own assertions. In fact, that's exactly what Rails does. It includes some specialized assertions to make your life easier.

NOTE: Creating your own assertions is an advanced topic that we won't cover in this tutorial.

### Rails Specific Assertions

418
Rails adds some custom assertions of its own to the `minitest` framework:
419 420 421 422 423 424 425

| Assertion                                                                         | Purpose |
| --------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------- |
| `assert_difference(expressions, difference = 1, message = nil) {...}`             | Test numeric difference between the return value of an expression as a result of what is evaluated in the yielded block.|
| `assert_no_difference(expressions, message = nil, &amp;block)`                    | Asserts that the numeric result of evaluating an expression is not changed before and after invoking the passed in block.|
| `assert_recognizes(expected_options, path, extras={}, message=nil)`               | Asserts that the routing of the given path was handled correctly and that the parsed options (given in the expected_options hash) match path. Basically, it asserts that Rails recognizes the route given by expected_options.|
| `assert_generates(expected_path, options, defaults={}, extras = {}, message=nil)` | Asserts that the provided options can be used to generate the provided path. This is the inverse of assert_recognizes. The extras parameter is used to tell the request the names and values of additional request parameters that would be in a query string. The message parameter allows you to specify a custom error message for assertion failures.|
426
| `assert_response(type, message = nil)`                                            | Asserts that the response comes with a specific status code. You can specify `:success` to indicate 200-299, `:redirect` to indicate 300-399, `:missing` to indicate 404, or `:error` to match the 500-599 range. You can also pass an explicit status number or its symbolic equivalent. For more information, see [full list of status codes](http://rubydoc.info/github/rack/rack/master/Rack/Utils#HTTP_STATUS_CODES-constant) and how their [mapping](http://rubydoc.info/github/rack/rack/master/Rack/Utils#SYMBOL_TO_STATUS_CODE-constant) works.|
427
| `assert_redirected_to(options = {}, message=nil)`                                 | Assert that the redirection options passed in match those of the redirect called in the latest action. This match can be partial, such that `assert_redirected_to(controller: "weblog")` will also match the redirection of `redirect_to(controller: "weblog", action: "show")` and so on. You can also pass named routes such as `assert_redirected_to root_path` and Active Record objects such as `assert_redirected_to @article`.|
428 429 430 431 432 433 434 435 436 437 438 439 440 441 442 443 444 445 446
| `assert_template(expected = nil, message=nil)`                                    | Asserts that the request was rendered with the appropriate template file.|

You'll see the usage of some of these assertions in the next chapter.

Functional Tests for Your Controllers
-------------------------------------

In Rails, testing the various actions of a single controller is called writing functional tests for that controller. Controllers handle the incoming web requests to your application and eventually respond with a rendered view.

### What to Include in your Functional Tests

You should test for things such as:

* was the web request successful?
* was the user redirected to the right page?
* was the user successfully authenticated?
* was the correct object stored in the response template?
* was the appropriate message displayed to the user in the view?

447
Now that we have used Rails scaffold generator for our `Article` resource, it has already created the controller code and tests. You can take look at the file `articles_controller_test.rb` in the `test/controllers` directory.
448

449
Let me take you through one such test, `test_should_get_index` from the file `articles_controller_test.rb`.
450 451

```ruby
452
class ArticlesControllerTest < ActionController::TestCase
453 454 455
  test "should get index" do
    get :index
    assert_response :success
456
    assert_not_nil assigns(:articles)
457
  end
458 459 460
end
```

461
In the `test_should_get_index` test, Rails simulates a request on the action called `index`, making sure the request was successful and also ensuring that it assigns a valid `articles` instance variable.
462 463 464 465

The `get` method kicks off the web request and populates the results into the response. It accepts 4 arguments:

* The action of the controller you are requesting. This can be in the form of a string or a symbol.
466
* An optional hash of request parameters to pass into the action (eg. query string parameters or article variables).
467 468 469 470 471 472 473 474 475 476 477 478 479 480 481
* An optional hash of session variables to pass along with the request.
* An optional hash of flash values.

Example: Calling the `:show` action, passing an `id` of 12 as the `params` and setting a `user_id` of 5 in the session:

```ruby
get(:show, {'id' => "12"}, {'user_id' => 5})
```

Another example: Calling the `:view` action, passing an `id` of 12 as the `params`, this time with no session, but with a flash message.

```ruby
get(:view, {'id' => '12'}, nil, {'message' => 'booya!'})
```

482
NOTE: If you try running `test_should_create_article` test from `articles_controller_test.rb` it will fail on account of the newly added model level validation and rightly so.
483

484
Let us modify `test_should_create_article` test in `articles_controller_test.rb` so that all our test pass:
485 486

```ruby
487 488 489
test "should create article" do
  assert_difference('Article.count') do
    post :create, article: {title: 'Some title'}
490 491
  end

492
  assert_redirected_to article_path(assigns(:article))
493 494 495 496 497 498 499 500 501 502 503 504 505 506 507 508 509 510 511 512 513 514
end
```

Now you can try running all the tests and they should pass.

### Available Request Types for Functional Tests

If you're familiar with the HTTP protocol, you'll know that `get` is a type of request. There are 6 request types supported in Rails functional tests:

* `get`
* `post`
* `patch`
* `put`
* `head`
* `delete`

All of request types are methods that you can use, however, you'll probably end up using the first two more often than the others.

NOTE: Functional tests do not verify whether the specified request type should be accepted by the action. Request types in this context exist to make your tests more descriptive.

### The Four Hashes of the Apocalypse

515
After a request has been made using one of the 6 methods (`get`, `post`, etc.) and processed, you will have 4 Hash objects ready for use:
516 517 518 519 520 521 522 523 524 525 526 527 528 529 530 531 532 533 534 535 536 537 538 539 540

* `assigns` - Any objects that are stored as instance variables in actions for use in views.
* `cookies` - Any cookies that are set.
* `flash` - Any objects living in the flash.
* `session` - Any object living in session variables.

As is the case with normal Hash objects, you can access the values by referencing the keys by string. You can also reference them by symbol name, except for `assigns`. For example:

```ruby
flash["gordon"]               flash[:gordon]
session["shmession"]          session[:shmession]
cookies["are_good_for_u"]     cookies[:are_good_for_u]

# Because you can't use assigns[:something] for historical reasons:
assigns["something"]          assigns(:something)
```

### Instance Variables Available

You also have access to three instance variables in your functional tests:

* `@controller` - The controller processing the request
* `@request` - The request
* `@response` - The response

541 542
### Setting Headers and CGI variables

543 544 545 546
[HTTP headers](http://tools.ietf.org/search/rfc2616#section-5.3)
and
[CGI variables](http://tools.ietf.org/search/rfc3875#section-4.1)
can be set directly on the `@request` instance variable:
547 548 549

```ruby
# setting a HTTP Header
550
@request.headers["Accept"] = "text/plain, text/html"
551 552 553 554 555 556 557
get :index # simulate the request with custom header

# setting a CGI variable
@request.headers["HTTP_REFERER"] = "http://example.com/home"
post :create # simulate the request with custom env variable
```

558 559 560 561 562 563 564 565 566
### Testing Templates and Layouts

If you want to make sure that the response rendered the correct template and layout, you can use the `assert_template`
method:

```ruby
test "index should render correct template and layout" do
  get :index
  assert_template :index
567
  assert_template layout: "layouts/application"
568 569 570 571 572 573 574 575 576
end
```

Note that you cannot test for template and layout at the same time, with one call to `assert_template` method.
Also, for the `layout` test, you can give a regular expression instead of a string, but using the string, makes
things clearer. On the other hand, you have to include the "layouts" directory name even if you save your layout
file in this standard layout directory. Hence,

```ruby
577
assert_template layout: "application"
578 579 580 581 582 583 584 585 586 587 588 589
```

will not work.

If your view renders any partial, when asserting for the layout, you have to assert for the partial at the same time.
Otherwise, assertion will fail.

Hence:

```ruby
test "new should render correct layout" do
  get :new
590
  assert_template layout: "layouts/application", partial: "_form"
591 592 593 594 595 596 597 598 599 600
end
```

is the correct way to assert for the layout when the view renders a partial with name `_form`. Omitting the `:partial` key in your `assert_template` call will complain.

### A Fuller Functional Test Example

Here's another example that uses `flash`, `assert_redirected_to`, and `assert_difference`:

```ruby
601
test "should create article" do
R
Robin Dupret 已提交
602
  assert_difference('Article.count') do
603
    post :create, article: {title: 'Hi', body: 'This is my first article.'}
604
  end
605 606
  assert_redirected_to article_path(assigns(:article))
  assert_equal 'Article was successfully created.', flash[:notice]
607 608 609 610 611 612 613
end
```

### Testing Views

Testing the response to your request by asserting the presence of key HTML elements and their content is a useful way to test the views of your application. The `assert_select` assertion allows you to do this by using a simple yet powerful syntax.

614
NOTE: You may find references to `assert_tag` in other documentation. This has been removed in 4.2. Use `assert_select` instead.
615 616 617

There are two forms of `assert_select`:

618
`assert_select(selector, [equality], [message])` ensures that the equality condition is met on the selected elements through the selector. The selector may be a CSS selector expression (String) or an expression with substitution values.
619

620
`assert_select(element, selector, [equality], [message])` ensures that the equality condition is met on all the selected elements through the selector starting from the _element_ (instance of `Nokogiri::XML::Node` or `Nokogiri::XML::NodeSet`) and its descendants.
621 622 623 624 625 626 627 628 629 630 631 632 633 634 635 636 637 638 639 640 641 642 643 644 645 646 647 648 649

For example, you could verify the contents on the title element in your response with:

```ruby
assert_select 'title', "Welcome to Rails Testing Guide"
```

You can also use nested `assert_select` blocks. In this case the inner `assert_select` runs the assertion on the complete collection of elements selected by the outer `assert_select` block:

```ruby
assert_select 'ul.navigation' do
  assert_select 'li.menu_item'
end
```

Alternatively the collection of elements selected by the outer `assert_select` may be iterated through so that `assert_select` may be called separately for each element. Suppose for example that the response contains two ordered lists, each with four list elements then the following tests will both pass.

```ruby
assert_select "ol" do |elements|
  elements.each do |element|
    assert_select element, "li", 4
  end
end

assert_select "ol" do
  assert_select "li", 8
end
```

650
The `assert_select` assertion is quite powerful. For more advanced usage, refer to its [documentation](https://github.com/rails/rails-dom-testing/blob/master/lib/rails/dom/testing/assertions/selector_assertions.rb).
651 652 653 654 655

#### Additional View-Based Assertions

There are more assertions that are primarily used in testing views:

S
Sunny Ripert 已提交
656 657 658 659 660
| Assertion                                                 | Purpose |
| --------------------------------------------------------- | ------- |
| `assert_select_email`                                     | Allows you to make assertions on the body of an e-mail. |
| `assert_select_encoded`                                   | Allows you to make assertions on encoded HTML. It does this by un-encoding the contents of each element and then calling the block with all the un-encoded elements.|
| `css_select(selector)` or `css_select(element, selector)` | Returns an array of all the elements selected by the _selector_. In the second variant it first matches the base _element_ and tries to match the _selector_ expression on any of its children. If there are no matches both variants return an empty array.|
661 662 663 664 665 666 667 668 669 670 671 672 673 674 675 676 677

Here's an example of using `assert_select_email`:

```ruby
assert_select_email do
  assert_select 'small', 'Please click the "Unsubscribe" link if you want to opt-out.'
end
```

Integration Testing
-------------------

Integration tests are used to test the interaction among any number of controllers. They are generally used to test important work flows within your application.

Unlike Unit and Functional tests, integration tests have to be explicitly created under the 'test/integration' folder within your application. Rails provides a generator to create an integration test skeleton for you.

```bash
678
$ bin/rails generate integration_test user_flows
679 680 681 682 683 684 685 686 687 688
      exists  test/integration/
      create  test/integration/user_flows_test.rb
```

Here's what a freshly-generated integration test looks like:

```ruby
require 'test_helper'

class UserFlowsTest < ActionDispatch::IntegrationTest
P
Prem Sichanugrist 已提交
689 690 691
  # test "the truth" do
  #   assert true
  # end
692 693 694 695 696 697 698 699 700 701 702 703 704 705 706 707 708 709 710 711 712 713 714 715 716 717 718 719 720 721 722 723 724 725 726 727 728 729
end
```

Integration tests inherit from `ActionDispatch::IntegrationTest`. This makes available some additional helpers to use in your integration tests. Also you need to explicitly include the fixtures to be made available to the test.

### Helpers Available for Integration Tests

In addition to the standard testing helpers, there are some additional helpers available to integration tests:

| Helper                                                             | Purpose |
| ------------------------------------------------------------------ | ------- |
| `https?`                                                           | Returns `true` if the session is mimicking a secure HTTPS request.|
| `https!`                                                           | Allows you to mimic a secure HTTPS request.|
| `host!`                                                            | Allows you to set the host name to use in the next request.|
| `redirect?`                                                        | Returns `true` if the last request was a redirect.|
| `follow_redirect!`                                                 | Follows a single redirect response.|
| `request_via_redirect(http_method, path, [parameters], [headers])` | Allows you to make an HTTP request and follow any subsequent redirects.|
| `post_via_redirect(path, [parameters], [headers])`                 | Allows you to make an HTTP POST request and follow any subsequent redirects.|
| `get_via_redirect(path, [parameters], [headers])`                  | Allows you to make an HTTP GET request and follow any subsequent redirects.|
| `patch_via_redirect(path, [parameters], [headers])`                | Allows you to make an HTTP PATCH request and follow any subsequent redirects.|
| `put_via_redirect(path, [parameters], [headers])`                  | Allows you to make an HTTP PUT request and follow any subsequent redirects.|
| `delete_via_redirect(path, [parameters], [headers])`               | Allows you to make an HTTP DELETE request and follow any subsequent redirects.|
| `open_session`                                                     | Opens a new session instance.|

### Integration Testing Examples

A simple integration test that exercises multiple controllers:

```ruby
require 'test_helper'

class UserFlowsTest < ActionDispatch::IntegrationTest
  test "login and browse site" do
    # login via https
    https!
    get "/login"
    assert_response :success

D
Deshi Xiao 已提交
730
    post_via_redirect "/login", username: users(:david).username, password: users(:david).password
731
    assert_equal '/welcome', path
D
Deshi Xiao 已提交
732
    assert_equal 'Welcome david!', flash[:notice]
733 734

    https!(false)
735
    get "/articles/all"
736
    assert_response :success
737
    assert assigns(:articles)
738 739 740 741 742 743 744 745 746 747 748 749 750
  end
end
```

As you can see the integration test involves multiple controllers and exercises the entire stack from database to dispatcher. In addition you can have multiple session instances open simultaneously in a test and extend those instances with assertion methods to create a very powerful testing DSL (domain-specific language) just for your application.

Here's an example of multiple sessions and custom DSL in an integration test

```ruby
require 'test_helper'

class UserFlowsTest < ActionDispatch::IntegrationTest
  test "login and browse site" do
751 752
    # User david logs in
    david = login(:david)
753 754 755 756
    # User guest logs in
    guest = login(:guest)

    # Both are now available in different sessions
757
    assert_equal 'Welcome david!', david.flash[:notice]
758 759
    assert_equal 'Welcome guest!', guest.flash[:notice]

760 761
    # User david can browse site
    david.browses_site
762 763 764 765 766 767 768 769
    # User guest can browse site as well
    guest.browses_site

    # Continue with other assertions
  end

  private

770 771 772 773 774 775
    module CustomDsl
      def browses_site
        get "/products/all"
        assert_response :success
        assert assigns(:products)
      end
776 777
    end

778 779 780 781 782 783
    def login(user)
      open_session do |sess|
        sess.extend(CustomDsl)
        u = users(user)
        sess.https!
        sess.post "/login", username: u.username, password: u.password
784
        assert_equal '/welcome', sess.path
785 786
        sess.https!(false)
      end
787 788 789 790 791 792 793
    end
end
```

Rake Tasks for Running your Tests
---------------------------------

J
Jon Atack 已提交
794 795 796
Rails comes with a number of built-in rake tasks to help with testing. The
table below lists the commands included in the default Rakefile when a Rails
project is created.
P
Prem Sichanugrist 已提交
797

V
Vijay Dev 已提交
798 799
| Tasks                   | Description |
| ----------------------- | ----------- |
800
| `rake test`             | Runs all tests in the `test` folder. You can also simply run `rake` as Rails will run all the tests by default |
801 802 803 804
| `rake test:controllers` | Runs all the controller tests from `test/controllers` |
| `rake test:functionals` | Runs all the functional tests from `test/controllers`, `test/mailers`, and `test/functional` |
| `rake test:helpers`     | Runs all the helper tests from `test/helpers` |
| `rake test:integration` | Runs all the integration tests from `test/integration` |
805
| `rake test:jobs`        | Runs all the job tests from `test/jobs` |
806 807 808
| `rake test:mailers`     | Runs all the mailer tests from `test/mailers` |
| `rake test:models`      | Runs all the model tests from `test/models` |
| `rake test:units`       | Runs all the unit tests from `test/models`, `test/helpers`, and `test/unit` |
809
| `rake test:db`          | Runs all tests in the `test` folder and resets the db |
810 811


J
Jon Atack 已提交
812
A Brief Note About Minitest
813 814
-----------------------------

815
Ruby ships with a vast Standard Library for all common use-cases including testing. Since version 1.9, Ruby provides `Minitest`, a framework for testing. All the basic assertions such as `assert_equal` discussed above are actually defined in `Minitest::Assertions`. The classes `ActiveSupport::TestCase`, `ActionController::TestCase`, `ActionMailer::TestCase`, `ActionView::TestCase` and `ActionDispatch::IntegrationTest` - which we have been inheriting in our test classes - include `Minitest::Assertions`, allowing us to use all of the basic assertions in our tests.
816

817
NOTE: For more information on `Minitest`, refer to [Minitest](http://ruby-doc.org/stdlib-2.1.0/libdoc/minitest/rdoc/MiniTest.html)
818 819 820 821

Setup and Teardown
------------------

822
If you would like to run a block of code before the start of each test and another block of code after the end of each test you have two special callbacks for your rescue. Let's take note of this by looking at an example for our functional test in `Articles` controller:
823 824 825 826

```ruby
require 'test_helper'

827
class ArticlesControllerTest < ActionController::TestCase
828 829 830

  # called before every single test
  def setup
831
    @article = articles(:one)
832 833 834 835
  end

  # called after every single test
  def teardown
836
    # as we are re-initializing @article before every test
837 838
    # setting it to nil here is not essential but I hope
    # you understand how you can use the teardown method
839
    @article = nil
840 841
  end

842 843
  test "should show article" do
    get :show, id: @article.id
844 845 846
    assert_response :success
  end

847 848 849
  test "should destroy article" do
    assert_difference('Article.count', -1) do
      delete :destroy, id: @article.id
850 851
    end

852
    assert_redirected_to articles_path
853 854 855 856 857
  end

end
```

858
Above, the `setup` method is called before each test and so `@article` is available for each of the tests. Rails implements `setup` and `teardown` as `ActiveSupport::Callbacks`. Which essentially means you need not only use `setup` and `teardown` as methods in your tests. You could specify them by using:
859 860 861 862 863 864 865 866 867

* a block
* a method (like in the earlier example)
* a method name as a symbol
* a lambda

Let's see the earlier example by specifying `setup` callback by specifying a method name as a symbol:

```ruby
868
require 'test_helper'
869

870
class ArticlesControllerTest < ActionController::TestCase
871 872

  # called before every single test
873
  setup :initialize_article
874 875 876

  # called after every single test
  def teardown
877
    @article = nil
878 879
  end

880 881
  test "should show article" do
    get :show, id: @article.id
882 883 884
    assert_response :success
  end

885 886 887
  test "should update article" do
    patch :update, id: @article.id, article: {}
    assert_redirected_to article_path(assigns(:article))
888 889
  end

890 891 892
  test "should destroy article" do
    assert_difference('Article.count', -1) do
      delete :destroy, id: @article.id
893 894
    end

895
    assert_redirected_to articles_path
896 897 898 899
  end

  private

900 901
    def initialize_article
      @article = articles(:one)
902
    end
903 904 905 906 907 908
end
```

Testing Routes
--------------

909
Like everything else in your Rails application, it is recommended that you test your routes. Below are example tests for the routes of default `show` and `create` action of `Articles` controller above and it should look like:
910 911

```ruby
C
Claudius Nicolae 已提交
912 913 914 915
class ArticleRoutesTest < ActionController::TestCase
  test "should route to article" do
    assert_routing '/articles/1', { controller: "articles", action: "show", id: "1" }
  end
916 917 918 919

  test "should route to create article" do
    assert_routing({ method: 'post', path: '/articles' }, { controller: "articles", action: "create" })
  end
920 921 922 923 924 925 926 927 928 929
end
```

Testing Your Mailers
--------------------

Testing mailer classes requires some specific tools to do a thorough job.

### Keeping the Postman in Check

930
Your mailer classes - like every other part of your Rails application - should be tested to ensure that it is working as expected.
931 932 933 934 935 936 937 938 939 940 941 942 943 944 945 946 947 948 949 950 951 952 953 954 955 956 957 958 959 960

The goals of testing your mailer classes are to ensure that:

* emails are being processed (created and sent)
* the email content is correct (subject, sender, body, etc)
* the right emails are being sent at the right times

#### From All Sides

There are two aspects of testing your mailer, the unit tests and the functional tests. In the unit tests, you run the mailer in isolation with tightly controlled inputs and compare the output to a known value (a fixture.) In the functional tests you don't so much test the minute details produced by the mailer; instead, we test that our controllers and models are using the mailer in the right way. You test to prove that the right email was sent at the right time.

### Unit Testing

In order to test that your mailer is working as expected, you can use unit tests to compare the actual results of the mailer with pre-written examples of what should be produced.

#### Revenge of the Fixtures

For the purposes of unit testing a mailer, fixtures are used to provide an example of how the output _should_ look. Because these are example emails, and not Active Record data like the other fixtures, they are kept in their own subdirectory apart from the other fixtures. The name of the directory within `test/fixtures` directly corresponds to the name of the mailer. So, for a mailer named `UserMailer`, the fixtures should reside in `test/fixtures/user_mailer` directory.

When you generated your mailer, the generator creates stub fixtures for each of the mailers actions. If you didn't use the generator you'll have to make those files yourself.

#### The Basic Test Case

Here's a unit test to test a mailer named `UserMailer` whose action `invite` is used to send an invitation to a friend. It is an adapted version of the base test created by the generator for an `invite` action.

```ruby
require 'test_helper'

class UserMailerTest < ActionMailer::TestCase
  test "invite" do
961 962
    # Send the email, then test that it got queued
    email = UserMailer.create_invite('me@example.com',
963
                                     'friend@example.com', Time.now).deliver_now
964
    assert_not ActionMailer::Base.deliveries.empty?
965 966 967 968 969 970

    # Test the body of the sent email contains what we expect it to
    assert_equal ['me@example.com'], email.from
    assert_equal ['friend@example.com'], email.to
    assert_equal 'You have been invited by me@example.com', email.subject
    assert_equal read_fixture('invite').join, email.body.to_s
971 972 973 974
  end
end
```

975 976 977 978
In the test we send the email and store the returned object in the `email`
variable. We then ensure that it was sent (the first assert), then, in the
second batch of assertions, we ensure that the email does indeed contain what we
expect. The helper `read_fixture` is used to read in the content from this file.
979 980 981 982 983 984 985 986 987 988 989

Here's the content of the `invite` fixture:

```
Hi friend@example.com,

You have been invited.

Cheers!
```

990 991 992 993 994 995
This is the right time to understand a little more about writing tests for your
mailers. The line `ActionMailer::Base.delivery_method = :test` in
`config/environments/test.rb` sets the delivery method to test mode so that
email will not actually be delivered (useful to avoid spamming your users while
testing) but instead it will be appended to an array
(`ActionMailer::Base.deliveries`).
996

997 998 999 1000
NOTE: The `ActionMailer::Base.deliveries` array is only reset automatically in
`ActionMailer::TestCase` tests. If you want to have a clean slate outside Action
Mailer tests, you can reset it manually with:
`ActionMailer::Base.deliveries.clear`
1001 1002 1003 1004 1005 1006 1007 1008 1009 1010 1011

### Functional Testing

Functional testing for mailers involves more than just checking that the email body, recipients and so forth are correct. In functional mail tests you call the mail deliver methods and check that the appropriate emails have been appended to the delivery list. It is fairly safe to assume that the deliver methods themselves do their job. You are probably more interested in whether your own business logic is sending emails when you expect them to go out. For example, you can check that the invite friend operation is sending an email appropriately:

```ruby
require 'test_helper'

class UserControllerTest < ActionController::TestCase
  test "invite friend" do
    assert_difference 'ActionMailer::Base.deliveries.size', +1 do
1012
      post :invite_friend, email: 'friend@example.com'
1013 1014 1015 1016 1017
    end
    invite_email = ActionMailer::Base.deliveries.last

    assert_equal "You have been invited by me@example.com", invite_email.subject
    assert_equal 'friend@example.com', invite_email.to[0]
1018
    assert_match(/Hi friend@example.com/, invite_email.body.to_s)
1019 1020 1021 1022
  end
end
```

1023 1024 1025 1026 1027
Testing helpers
---------------

In order to test helpers, all you need to do is check that the output of the
helper method matches what you'd expect. Tests related to the helpers are
1028
located under the `test/helpers` directory.
1029

1030
A helper test looks like so:
1031 1032 1033 1034 1035 1036 1037 1038 1039 1040 1041 1042 1043 1044 1045 1046 1047 1048 1049 1050 1051 1052 1053 1054 1055

```ruby
require 'test_helper'

class UserHelperTest < ActionView::TestCase
end
```

A helper is just a simple module where you can define methods which are
available into your views. To test the output of the helper's methods, you just
have to use a mixin like this:

```ruby
class UserHelperTest < ActionView::TestCase
  include UserHelper

  test "should return the user name" do
    # ...
  end
end
```

Moreover, since the test class extends from `ActionView::TestCase`, you have
access to Rails' helper methods such as `link_to` or `pluralize`.

1056 1057 1058 1059 1060 1061 1062 1063 1064 1065 1066 1067 1068 1069 1070 1071 1072 1073 1074 1075 1076 1077 1078 1079 1080 1081 1082 1083 1084 1085 1086 1087 1088 1089 1090 1091 1092 1093 1094 1095 1096 1097 1098 1099 1100 1101 1102 1103 1104 1105 1106 1107 1108 1109 1110 1111 1112 1113 1114 1115 1116 1117
Testing Jobs
------------

Since your custom jobs can be queued at different levels inside your application,
you'll need to test both jobs themselves (their behavior when they get enqueued)
and that other entities correctly enqueue them.

### A Basic Test Case

By default, when you generate a job, an associated test will be generated as well
under the `test/jobs` directory. Here's an example test with a billing job:

```ruby
require 'test_helper'

class BillingJobTest < ActiveJob::TestCase
  test 'that account is charged' do
    BillingJob.perform_now(account, product)
    assert account.reload.charged_for?(product)
  end
end
```

This test is pretty simple and only asserts that the job get the work done
as expected.

By default, `ActiveJob::TestCase` will set the queue adapter to `:test` so that
your jobs are performed inline. It will also ensure that all previously performed
and enqueued jobs are cleared before any test run so you can safely assume that
no jobs have already been executed in the scope of each test.

### Custom Assertions And Testing Jobs Inside Other Components

Active Job ships with a bunch of custom assertions that can be used to lessen
the verbosity of tests:

| Assertion                              | Purpose |
| -------------------------------------- | ------- |
| `assert_enqueued_jobs(number)`         | Asserts that the number of enqueued jobs matches the given number. |
| `assert_performed_jobs(number)`        | Asserts that the number of performed jobs matches the given number. |
| `assert_no_enqueued_jobs { ... }`      | Asserts that no jobs have been enqueued. |
| `assert_no_performed_jobs { ... }`     | Asserts that no jobs have been performed. |
| `assert_enqueued_with([args]) { ... }` | Asserts that the job passed in the block has been enqueued with the given arguments. |
| `assert_performed_with([args]) { ... }`| Asserts that the job passed in the block has been performed with the given arguments. |

It's a good practice to ensure that your jobs correctly get enqueued or performed
wherever you invoke them (e.g. inside your controllers). This is precisely where
the custom assertions provided by Active Job are pretty useful. For instance,
within a model:

```ruby
require 'test_helper'

class ProductTest < ActiveSupport::TestCase
  test 'billing job scheduling' do
    assert_enqueued_with(job: BillingJob) do
      product.charge(account)
    end
  end
end
```

1118 1119 1120
Other Testing Approaches
------------------------

1121
The built-in `minitest` based testing is not the only way to test Rails applications. Rails developers have come up with a wide variety of other approaches and aids for testing, including:
1122 1123 1124

* [NullDB](http://avdi.org/projects/nulldb/), a way to speed up testing by avoiding database use.
* [Factory Girl](https://github.com/thoughtbot/factory_girl/tree/master), a replacement for fixtures.
1125
* [Fixture Builder](https://github.com/rdy/fixture_builder), a tool that compiles Ruby factories into fixtures before a test run.
1126
* [MiniTest::Spec Rails](https://github.com/metaskills/minitest-spec-rails), use the MiniTest::Spec DSL within your rails tests.
1127 1128
* [Shoulda](http://www.thoughtbot.com/projects/shoulda), an extension to `test/unit` with additional helpers, macros, and assertions.
* [RSpec](http://relishapp.com/rspec), a behavior-driven development framework
1129
* [Capybara](http://jnicklas.github.com/capybara/), Acceptance test framework for web applications