Reorder first secrets edit flow.

Setup config/secrets.yml.enc with template contents for people to edit.

Then generate encryption key and encrypt the initial secrets.

railties/lib/rails/commands/secrets/secrets_command.rb

@@ -13,10 +13,7 @@ def help
       end
 
       def setup
-        require "rails/generators"
-        require "rails/generators/rails/encrypted_secrets/encrypted_secrets_generator"
-
-        Rails::Generators::EncryptedSecretsGenerator.start
+        generator.start
       end
 
       def edit
@@ -42,7 +39,22 @@ def edit
         say "Aborted changing encrypted secrets: nothing saved."
       rescue Rails::Secrets::MissingKeyError => error
         say error.message
+      rescue Errno::ENOENT => error
+        raise unless error.message =~ /secrets\.yml\.enc/
+
+        Rails::Secrets.read_template_for_editing do |tmp_path|
+          system("\$EDITOR #{tmp_path}")
+          generator.skip_secrets_file { setup }
+        end
       end
+
+      private
+        def generator
+          require "rails/generators"
+          require "rails/generators/rails/encrypted_secrets/encrypted_secrets_generator"
+
+          Rails::Generators::EncryptedSecretsGenerator
+        end
     end
   end
 end

railties/lib/rails/generators/rails/encrypted_secrets/encrypted_secrets_generator.rb

@@ -36,25 +36,29 @@ def ignore_key_file
       end
 
       def add_encrypted_secrets_file
-        unless File.exist?("config/secrets.yml.enc")
+        unless (defined?(@@skip_secrets_file) && @@skip_secrets_file) || File.exist?("config/secrets.yml.enc")
           say "Adding config/secrets.yml.enc to store secrets that needs to be encrypted."
           say ""
+          say "For now the file contains this but it's been encrypted with the generated key:"
+          say ""
+          say Secrets.template, :on_green
+          say ""
 
-          template "config/secrets.yml.enc" do |prefill|
-            say ""
-            say "For now the file contains this but it's been encrypted with the generated key:"
-            say ""
-            say prefill, :on_green
-            say ""
-
-            Secrets.encrypt(prefill)
-          end
+          Secrets.write(Secrets.template)
 
           say "You can edit encrypted secrets with `bin/rails secrets:edit`."
-
-          say "Add this to your config/environments/production.rb:"
-          say "config.read_encrypted_secrets = true"
+          say ""
         end
+
+        say "Add this to your config/environments/production.rb:"
+        say "config.read_encrypted_secrets = true"
+      end
+
+      def self.skip_secrets_file
+        @@skip_secrets_file = true
+        yield
+      ensure
+        @@skip_secrets_file = false
       end
 
       private

railties/lib/rails/generators/rails/encrypted_secrets/templates/config/secrets.yml.enc

-# See `secrets.yml` for tips on generating suitable keys.
-# production:
-#  external_api_key: 1466aac22e6a869134be3d09b9e89232fc2c2289…

railties/lib/rails/secrets.rb

 require "yaml"
 require "active_support/message_encryptor"
+require "active_support/core_ext/string/strip"
 
 module Rails
   # Greatly inspired by Ara T. Howard's magnificent sekrets gem. 😘
@@ -37,6 +38,15 @@ def key
         ENV["RAILS_MASTER_KEY"] || read_key_file || handle_missing_key
       end
 
+      def template
+        <<-end_of_template.strip_heredoc
+          # See `secrets.yml` for tips on generating suitable keys.
+          # production:
+          #  external_api_key: 1466aac22e6a869134be3d09b9e89232fc2c2289…
+
+        end_of_template
+      end
+
       def encrypt(data)
         encryptor.encrypt_and_sign(data)
       end
@@ -54,15 +64,12 @@ def write(contents)
         FileUtils.mv("#{path}.tmp", path)
       end
 
-      def read_for_editing
-        tmp_path = File.join(Dir.tmpdir, File.basename(path))
-        IO.binwrite(tmp_path, read)
-
-        yield tmp_path
+      def read_for_editing(&block)
+        writing(read, &block)
+      end
 
-        write(IO.binread(tmp_path))
-      ensure
-        FileUtils.rm(tmp_path) if File.exist?(tmp_path)
+      def read_template_for_editing(&block)
+        writing(template, &block)
       end
 
       private
@@ -92,6 +99,17 @@ def preprocess(path)
           end
         end
 
+        def writing(contents)
+          tmp_path = File.join(Dir.tmpdir, File.basename(path))
+          File.write(tmp_path, contents)
+
+          yield tmp_path
+
+          write(File.read(tmp_path))
+        ensure
+          FileUtils.rm(tmp_path) if File.exist?(tmp_path)
+        end
+
         def encryptor
           @encryptor ||= ActiveSupport::MessageEncryptor.new([ key ].pack("H*"), cipher: @cipher)
         end

railties/test/commands/secrets_test.rb

@@ -18,7 +18,8 @@ def teardown
   end
 
   test "edit secrets" do
-    run_setup_command
+    # Runs setup before first edit.
+    assert_match(/Adding config\/secrets\.yml\.key to store the encryption key/, run_edit_command)
 
     # Run twice to ensure encrypted secrets can be reread after first edit pass.
     2.times do
@@ -30,8 +31,4 @@ def teardown
     def run_edit_command(editor: "cat")
       Dir.chdir(app_path) { `EDITOR="#{editor}" bin/rails secrets:edit` }
     end
-
-    def run_setup_command
-      Dir.chdir(app_path) { `bin/rails secrets:setup` }
-    end
 end