check_api_approvals.sh 18.5 KB
Newer Older
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27
#!/bin/bash
if [ -z ${BRANCH} ]; then
    BRANCH="develop"
fi

PADDLE_ROOT="$( cd "$( dirname "${BASH_SOURCE[0]}")/../" && pwd )"
API_FILES=("CMakeLists.txt"
           "paddle/fluid/op_use_default_grad_op_maker.spec"
           "paddle/fluid/framework/operator.h"
           "paddle/fluid/framework/tensor.h"
           "paddle/fluid/framework/details/op_registry.h"
           "paddle/fluid/framework/grad_op_desc_maker.h"
           "paddle/fluid/framework/lod_tensor.h"
           "paddle/fluid/framework/selected_rows.h"
           "paddle/fluid/framework/op_desc.h"
           "paddle/fluid/framework/block_desc.h"
           "paddle/fluid/framework/var_desc.h"
           "paddle/fluid/framework/scope.h"
           "paddle/fluid/framework/ir/node.h"
           "paddle/fluid/framework/ir/graph.h"
           "paddle/fluid/framework/framework.proto"
           "python/requirements.txt"
           "python/paddle/fluid/__init__.py"
           "python/paddle/fluid/compiler.py"
           "python/paddle/fluid/parallel_executor.py"
           "python/paddle/fluid/framework.py"
           "python/paddle/fluid/backward.py"
28
           "paddle/fluid/operators/distributed/send_recv.proto.in"
29
           "paddle/fluid/framework/unused_var_check.cc"
30
           "python/paddle/fluid/tests/unittests/white_list/check_shape_white_list.py"
31 32
           "python/paddle/fluid/tests/unittests/white_list/op_accuracy_white_list.py"
           )
33 34 35 36 37 38

approval_line=`curl -H "Authorization: token ${GITHUB_API_TOKEN}" https://api.github.com/repos/PaddlePaddle/Paddle/pulls/${GIT_PR_ID}/reviews?per_page=10000`
git_files=`git diff --numstat upstream/$BRANCH| wc -l`
git_count=`git diff --numstat upstream/$BRANCH| awk '{sum+=$1}END{print sum}'`
failed_num=0
echo_list=()
39 40 41 42 43


function check_approval(){
    person_num=`echo $@|awk '{for (i=2;i<=NF;i++)print $i}'`
    APPROVALS=`echo ${approval_line}|python ${PADDLE_ROOT}/tools/check_pr_approval.py $1 $person_num`
T
tianshuo78520a 已提交
44
    if [[ "${APPROVALS}" == "FALSE" && "${echo_line}" != "" ]]; then
45
        add_failed "${failed_num}. ${echo_line}"
46 47 48 49 50
    fi
}


function add_failed(){
51
    failed_num=`expr $failed_num + 1`
52
    echo_list="${echo_list[@]}$1"
53 54 55 56
} 


if [[ $git_files -gt 19 || $git_count -gt 999 ]];then
57
    echo_line="You must have Dianhai approval for change 20+ files or add than 1000+ lines of content.\n"
58
    check_approval 1 38231817
59 60
fi    

T
tianshuo78520a 已提交
61
api_spec_diff=`python ${PADDLE_ROOT}/tools/diff_api.py ${PADDLE_ROOT}/paddle/fluid/API_DEV.spec.api  ${PADDLE_ROOT}/paddle/fluid/API_PR.spec.api` 
Z
Zeng Jinle 已提交
62
if [ "$api_spec_diff" != "" ]; then
T
tianshuo78520a 已提交
63
    echo_line="You must have one RD (XiaoguangHu01 or lanxianghit) and one TPM (saxon-zh or Boyan-Liu or swtkiwi) approval for the api change for the management reason of API interface.\n"
T
tianshuo78520a 已提交
64
    check_approval 1 46782768 47554610
T
tianshuo78520a 已提交
65
    echo_line=""
T
tianshuo78520a 已提交
66
    check_approval 1 2870059 2870059 27208573 
T
tianshuo78520a 已提交
67 68 69 70
fi

api_doc_spec_diff=`python ${PADDLE_ROOT}/tools/diff_api.py ${PADDLE_ROOT}/paddle/fluid/API_DEV.spec.doc  ${PADDLE_ROOT}/paddle/fluid/API_PR.spec.doc` 
if [ "$api_doc_spec_diff" != "" ]; then
T
tianshuo78520a 已提交
71 72
    echo_line="You must have one TPM (saxon-zh or Boyan-Liu or swtkiwi) approval for the api change for the management reason of API document.\n"
    check_approval 1 31623103 2870059 27208573
Z
Zeng Jinle 已提交
73 74
fi

75 76
op_type_spec_diff=`python ${PADDLE_ROOT}/tools/check_op_register_type.py ${PADDLE_ROOT}/paddle/fluid/OP_TYPE_DEV.spec  ${PADDLE_ROOT}/paddle/fluid/OP_TYPE_PR.spec`
if [ "$op_type_spec_diff" != "" ]; then
77
    echo_line="You must have one RD (Aurelius84 (Recommend) or liym27 or zhhsplendid)approval for the data_type registration of new operator. More data_type of new operator should be registered in your PR. Please make sure that both float/double (or int/int64_t) have been registered.\n For more details, please click [https://github.com/PaddlePaddle/Paddle/wiki/Data-types-of-generic-Op-must-be-fully-registered].\n"
78 79
    check_approval 1 9301846 33742067 7913861
fi
T
tianshuo78520a 已提交
80

81 82
op_desc_diff=`python ${PADDLE_ROOT}/tools/check_op_desc.py ${PADDLE_ROOT}/paddle/fluid/OP_DESC_DEV.spec  ${PADDLE_ROOT}/paddle/fluid/OP_DESC_PR.spec`
if [ "$op_desc_diff" != "" ]; then
83
    echo_line="You must have one RD (liym27 (Recommend), zhhsplendid, Aurelius84, lanxianghit or phlrain) approval for the changes of Inputs/Output/Attrs of OPs. The changes of OPs will cause that the new version inference fails to load model trained by the old version. Please modify your code. \n For more details, please click [https://github.com/PaddlePaddle/Paddle/wiki/OP-Input-Output-Attribute-Compatibility-Modification].\n${op_desc_diff}\n"
84 85 86
    check_approval 1 33742067 7913861 9301846 47554610 43953930
fi

87 88 89
for API_FILE in ${API_FILES[*]}; do
  API_CHANGE=`git diff --name-only upstream/$BRANCH | grep "${API_FILE}" | grep -v "/CMakeLists.txt" || true`
  if [ "${API_CHANGE}" ] && [ "${GIT_PR_ID}" != "" ]; then
90
      # NOTE: per_page=10000 should be ok for all cases, a PR review > 10000 is not human readable.
91
      # You can use http://caius.github.io/github_id/ to find Github user id.
92
      # approval_user_list: XiaoguangHu01 46782768,Xreki 12538138,luotao1 6836917,sneaxiy 32832641,qingqing01 7845005,guoshengCS 14105589,heavengate 12605721,kuke 3064195,Superjomn 328693,lanxianghit 47554610,cyj1986 39645414,hutuxian 11195205,frankwhzhang 20274488,nepeplwu 45024560,Dianhai 38231817,chenwhql 22561442,zhiqiu 6888866,seiriosPlus 5442383,gongweibao 10721757,saxon-zh 2870059,Boyan-Liu 31623103, zhouwei25 52485244, Aurelius84 9301846, liym27 33742067, zhhsplendid 7913861, kolinwei 22165420, liuwei1031 46661762, swtkiwi 27208573, juncaipeng 52520497, zhangting2020 26615455.
Z
Zeng Jinle 已提交
93
      if [ "${API_FILE}" == "paddle/fluid/op_use_default_grad_op_maker.spec" ];then
94 95
          echo_line="You must have one RD (sneaxiy (Recommend) or luotao1) approval for op_use_default_grad_op_maker.spec, which manages the grad_op memory optimization.\n"
          check_approval 1 32832641 6836917
96
      elif [ "${API_FILE}" == "CMakeLists.txt" ];then
97 98
          echo_line="You must have one RD (luotao1 or XiaoguangHu01) approval for CMakeLists.txt, which manages the compilation parameter.\n"
          check_approval 1 6836917 46782768
99
      elif [ "${API_FILE}" == "python/paddle/fluid/__init__.py" ];then
100 101
          echo_line="You must have one RD (lanxianghit (Recommend) or luotao1) approval for the python/paddle/fluid/init.py, which manages the environment variables.\n"
          check_approval 1 6836917 47554610
102 103
      elif [ "${API_FILE}" == "python/requirements.txt" ];then
          echo_line="You must have one RD (JiabinYang (Recommend) or luotao1) approval for python/requirements.txt, which manages the third-party python package.\n"
104 105
          check_approval 1 6836917 22361972
      elif [ "${API_FILE}" == "paddle/fluid/operators/distributed/send_recv.proto.in" ];then
106
          echo_line="You must have one RD (gongweibao or seiriosPlus) approval for the paddle/fluid/operators/distributed/send_recv.proto.in, which manages the environment variables.\n"
107
          check_approval 1 10721757 5442383
108
      elif [ "${API_FILE}" == "paddle/fluid/framework/unused_var_check.cc" ];then
109
          echo_line="You must have one RD (zhiqiu (Recommend) , sneaxiy or luotao1) approval for the paddle/fluid/framework/unused_var_check.cc, which manages the white list of operators that have unused input variables. Before change the white list, please read the specification [https://github.com/PaddlePaddle/Paddle/wiki/OP-Should-Not-Have-Unused-Input] and try to refine code first. \n"
110
          check_approval 1 6888866 32832641 6836917
111 112 113
      elif [ "${API_FILE}" == "python/paddle/fluid/tests/unittests/white_list/check_shape_white_list.py" ];then
          echo_line="You must have one RD (hong19860320 (Recommend), luotao1, phlrain) approval for the changes of check_shape_white_list.py, which manages the white list of operators with limited input size. The op test must have at least one test case with input size greater than or equal to 100. For more information, please refer to: https://github.com/PaddlePaddle/Paddle/wiki/OP-Test-Input-Shape-Requirements. \n"
          check_approval 1 9973393 6836917 43953930
114 115 116
      elif [ "${API_FILE}" == "python/paddle/fluid/tests/unittests/white_list/op_accuracy_white_list.py" ];then
          echo_line="You must have one RD (juncaipeng (Recommend), zhangting2020 (Recommend) or luotao1) approval for the python/paddle/fluid/tests/unittests/white_list/op_accuracy_white_list.py, which manages the white list of upgrading the precision of op test to float64. For more information, please refer to: https://github.com/PaddlePaddle/Paddle/wiki/Upgrade-OP-Precision-to-Float64. \n"
          check_approval 1 52520497 26615455 6836917
117
      else
T
tianshuo78520a 已提交
118
          echo_line="You must have one RD (XiaoguangHu01,Xreki,luotao1,sneaxiy) approval for ${API_FILE}, which manages the underlying code for fluid.\n"
119
          check_approval 1 3048612 46782768 12538138 6836917 32832641
120 121 122 123 124 125
      fi
  fi
done

HAS_CONST_CAST=`git diff -U0 upstream/$BRANCH |grep -o -m 1 "const_cast" || true`
if [ ${HAS_CONST_CAST} ] && [ "${GIT_PR_ID}" != "" ]; then
126 127
    echo_line="You must have one RD (XiaoguangHu01,Xreki,luotao1,sneaxiy) approval for the usage (either add or delete) of const_cast.\n"
    check_approval 1 3048612 46782768 12538138 6836917 32832641
128 129 130 131
fi

HAS_DEFINE_FLAG=`git diff -U0 upstream/$BRANCH |grep -o -m 1 "DEFINE_int32" |grep -o -m 1 "DEFINE_bool" | grep -o -m 1 "DEFINE_string" || true`
if [ ${HAS_DEFINE_FLAG} ] && [ "${GIT_PR_ID}" != "" ]; then
132
    echo_line="You must have one RD lanxianghit approval for the usage (either add or delete) of DEFINE_int32/DEFINE_bool/DEFINE_string flag.\n"
133
    check_approval 1 47554610
134 135
fi

136 137
HAS_UNITTEST_SKIP=`git diff -U0 upstream/$BRANCH | grep "^+[[:space:]]\{0,\}@unittest.skip" || true`
if [ "${HAS_UNITTEST_SKIP}" != "" ] && [ "${GIT_PR_ID}" != "" ]; then
138 139 140
    echo_line="Unittest is not allowed to be disabled.\nYou must have one RD (kolinwei(Recommend), liuwei1031, or luotao1) approval for the usage of @unittest.skip or @unittest.skipIf.\n${HAS_UNITTEST_SKIP}\n"
    check_approval 1 22165420 6836917 46661762
  fi
141

142 143
ALL_PADDLE_ENFORCE=`git diff -U0 upstream/$BRANCH |grep "+" |grep -zoE "PADDLE_ENFORCE\(.[^,\);]+.[^;]*\);\s" || true`
if [ "${ALL_PADDLE_ENFORCE}" != "" ] && [ "${GIT_PR_ID}" != "" ]; then
144
    echo_line="PADDLE_ENFORCE is not recommended. Please use PADDLE_ENFORCE_EQ/NE/GT/GE/LT/LE or PADDLE_ENFORCE_NOT_NULL or PADDLE_ENFORCE_CUDA_SUCCESS instead, see [ https://github.com/PaddlePaddle/Paddle/wiki/PADDLE_ENFORCE-Rewriting-Specification ] for details.\nYou must have one RD (chenwhql (Recommend) , luotao1 (Recommend) or lanxianghit) approval for the usage (either add or delete) of PADDLE_ENFORCE.\n${ALL_PADDLE_ENFORCE}\n"
145
    check_approval 1 6836917 47554610 22561442
146 147 148 149
fi

ALL_PADDLE_CHECK=`git diff -U0 upstream/$BRANCH |grep "+" |grep -zoE "(PADDLE_ENFORCE[A-Z_]{0,9}|PADDLE_THROW)\(.[^,\);]*.[^;]*\);\s" || true`
VALID_PADDLE_CHECK=`echo "$ALL_PADDLE_CHECK" | grep -zoE '(PADDLE_ENFORCE[A-Z_]{0,9}|PADDLE_THROW)\((.[^,;]+,)*.[^";]*(errors::).[^"]*".[^";]{20,}.[^;]*\);\s' || true`
150
INVALID_PADDLE_CHECK=`echo "$ALL_PADDLE_CHECK" |grep -vxF "$VALID_PADDLE_CHECK" || true`
151
if [ "${INVALID_PADDLE_CHECK}" != "" ] && [ "${GIT_PR_ID}" != "" ]; then
T
Tao Luo 已提交
152
    echo_line="The error message you wrote in PADDLE_ENFORCE{_**} or PADDLE_THROW does not meet our error message writing specification. Possible errors include 1. the error message is empty / 2. the error message is too short / 3. the error type is not specified. Please read the specification [ https://github.com/PaddlePaddle/Paddle/wiki/Paddle-Error-Message-Writing-Specification ], then refine the error message. If it is a mismatch, please specify chenwhql (Recommend), luotao1 or lanxianghit review and approve.\nThe PADDLE_ENFORCE{_**} or PADDLE_THROW entries that do not meet the specification are as follows:\n${INVALID_PADDLE_CHECK}\n"
153
    check_approval 1 6836917 47554610 22561442
154 155
fi

156 157 158 159 160
NEW_OP_ADDED=`git diff --name-only --diff-filter=A upstream/$BRANCH |grep -oE ".+_op..*" || true`
if [ "${NEW_OP_ADDED}" != "" ] && [ "${GIT_PR_ID}" != "" ]; then
    GET_KERNEL_TYPE_FUNC_CNT=`git diff -U0 --diff-filter=A upstream/$BRANCH |grep "+" |grep -czoE "GetExpectedKernelType[(][^(){}]+[)][^{]+[{][^}]+[}]" || true`
    INDICATE_VAR_DTYPE_CNT=`git diff -U0 --diff-filter=A upstream/$BRANCH |grep "+" |grep -co "IndicateVarDataType" || true`
    if [ ${GET_KERNEL_TYPE_FUNC_CNT} -gt ${INDICATE_VAR_DTYPE_CNT} ]; then
161 162
        echo_line="If you override GetExpectedKernelType method of OperatorWithKernel, please use OperatorWithKernel::IndicateVarDataType() method to get specific input variable's dtype, which checked whether the input variable is initialized (The details in https://github.com/PaddlePaddle/FluidDoc/pull/1527). If you don't use this method to check, you must have one RD (chenwhql (Recommend) , luotao1 or lanxianghit) approval for the usage of other methods.\n"
        check_approval 1 6836917 47554610 22561442
163 164 165
    fi
fi

W
Wilber 已提交
166 167 168 169 170 171
HAS_OPERATORBASE_FLAG=`git diff -U0 --diff-filter=A upstream/$BRANCH | grep -E "public[[:space:]]+.*OperatorBase" || true`
if [ "${HAS_OPERATORBASE_FLAG}" != "" ] && [ "${GIT_PR_ID}" != "" ]; then
    echo_line="In order to support dynamic graph, all ops are not recommedned to inherit OperatorBase. Please use OperatorWithKernel instead.\nYou must have one RD (phlrain (Recommend), luotao1, lanxianghit or XiaoguangHu01) approval for the inherit of OperatorBase.\nYou inherit the OperatorBase class. The corresponding lines are as follows:\n${HAS_OPERATORBASE_FLAG}"
    check_approval 1 47554610 46782768 22561442 6836917
fi

172 173 174 175 176 177
HAS_INPLACE_TESTS=`git diff -U0 upstream/$BRANCH |grep "+" |grep -E "inplace_atol[[:space:]]*=.*" || true`
if [ "${HAS_INPLACE_TESTS}" != "" ] && [ "${GIT_PR_ID}" != "" ]; then
    echo_line="The calculation results of setting inplace enabled and disabled must be equal, that is, it's not recommended to set inplace_atol.\n If you do need to use inplace_atol, you must have one RD (XiaoguangHu01, lanxianghit, phlrain, luotao1) approval for the usage of inplace_atol.\nThe corresponding lines are as follows:\n${HAS_INPLACE_TESTS}\n"
    check_approval 1 46782768 47554610 43953930 6836917
fi

178 179 180 181 182 183 184
HAS_COMPILERUNTIME_NOT_TEST=`git diff -U0 --diff-filter=A upstream/$BRANCH |grep "+" |grep -E "check_output[(]*check_compile_vs_runtime=False" || true`
if [ "${HAS_COMPILERUNTIME_NOT_TEST}" != "" ] && [ "${GIT_PR_ID}" != "" ]; then
    echo_line="If the operator's output after infershape() is a LodTensor, the output's Lod-Level during compile-time and runtime must be equal. Please set check_compile_vs_runtime=True in op_test.check_output function to enable compile&runtime lod-level check.\n
If you do not need check_compile_vs_runtime, you must have one RD (lanxianghit, phlrain, luotao1) approval.\nThe corresponding lines are as follows:\n${HAS_COMPILERUNTIME_NOT_TEST}\n"
    check_approval 1 47554610 43953930 6836917
fi

185 186 187 188 189 190 191 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 199 200
OP_FILE_CHANGED=`git diff --name-only --diff-filter=AMR upstream/$BRANCH |grep -oE ".+_op..*" || true`
if [ "${OP_FILE_CHANGED}" != "" ] && [ "${GIT_PR_ID}" != "" ]; then
    for OP_FILE in ${OP_FILE_CHANGED};
    do
        CHECK_OBJECT_FLAGS=`git diff -U0 upstream/$BRANCH ${PADDLE_ROOT}/${OP_FILE} |grep "+" |grep -E "ShareDataWith[(]|ShareBufferWith[(]" || true`
        if [ "${CHECK_OBJECT_FLAGS}" != "" ]; then
            ERROR_LINES="${ERROR_LINES}\n${OP_FILE}${CHECK_OBJECT_FLAGS}\n"
        fi
    done
    if [ "${ERROR_LINES}" != "" ]; then
        ERROR_LINES=${ERROR_LINES//+/'\n+\t'}
        echo_line="Using ShareDataWith or ShareBufferWith is not recommended. You must have one RD's (zhhsplendid (Recommend), sneaxiy or luotao1 or lanxianghit) approval to use these methods. For more information, please refer to https://github.com/PaddlePaddle/Paddle/wiki/ShareDataWith-is-prohibited-in-OP. The error lines are as follows:${ERROR_LINES}"
        check_approval 1 6836917 32832641 47554610 7913861
    fi
fi

G
GaoWei8 已提交
201 202 203
NEW_OP_TEST_ADDED=`git diff --name-only --diff-filter=AMR upstream/$BRANCH |grep -oE "test_.*.\.py" || true`
if [ "${NEW_OP_TEST_ADDED}" != "" ] && [ "${GIT_PR_ID}" != "" ]; then
    CHECK_OUTPUT=`git diff -U5 --diff-filter=AMR upstream/$BRANCH |grep "self\.check_output(a*t*o*l*=*[0-9]"|grep "+" || true`
204
    CHECK_OUTPUT_WITH_PLACE=`git diff -U5 --diff-filter=AMR upstream/$BRANCH |grep -A2 "self\.check_output_with_place" |grep ", [atol*,0-9]"|grep "+" || true`
G
GaoWei8 已提交
205 206 207 208 209 210 211 212 213 214
    CHECK_GRAD=`git diff -U5 --diff-filter=AMR upstream/$BRANCH |grep -A5 -E "self\.check_grad|self\.check_grad_with_place"|grep "max_relative_error=" |grep "+" || true`
    CHECK_GRAD_CHECK=`git diff -U5 --diff-filter=AMR upstream/$BRANCH |grep -A2 -E "checker\.double_grad_check"|grep "eps=|atol=|rtol=" |grep "+" || true`
    CHECK_WHOLE=$CHECK_OUTPUT$CHECK_OUTPUT_WITH_PLACE$CHECK_GRAD$CHECK_GRAD_CHECK
    if [ "${CHECK_WHOLE}" != "" ] ; then
        CHECK_OP=${CHECK_WHOLE//+/'\n+'}       
        echo_line="Please use the default precision parameters of 'atol, rtol, eps, max_relative_error'. If you don't use the default value, you must have one RD (Xreki (Recommend), luotao1, lanxianghit or phlrain) approval for the usage of other values. The detailed information is in the link: https://github.cor/PaddlePaddle/Paddle/wiki/OP-test-accuracy-requirements. The error line is ${CHECK_OP}\n"
        check_approval 1 6836917 47554610 12538138 43953930
    fi
fi

215 216 217 218 219 220 221 222 223 224 225 226 227 228 229 230
UNITTEST_FILE_CHANGED=`git diff --name-only --diff-filter=AM upstream/$BRANCH |grep -E "test_.*.\.py" || true`
if [ "${UNITTEST_FILE_CHANGED}" != "" ] && [ "${GIT_PR_ID}" != "" ]; then
    for TEST_FILE in ${UNITTEST_FILE_CHANGED};
    do
        HAS_SKIP_CHECK_GRAD_CI=`git diff -U0 upstream/$BRANCH ${PADDLE_ROOT}/${TEST_FILE} |grep "@skip_check_grad_ci" || true`
        if [ "${HAS_SKIP_CHECK_GRAD_CI}" != "" ]; then
            ERROR_LINES="${ERROR_LINES}\n${TEST_FILE}\n${HAS_SKIP_CHECK_GRAD_CI}\n"
        fi
    done
    if [ "${ERROR_LINES}" != "" ]; then
        ERROR_LINES=${ERROR_LINES//+/'\n+\t'}
        echo_line="You must have one RD (zhangting2020 (Recommend), luotao1 or phlrain) approval for the usage (either add or delete) of @skip_check_grad_ci. For more information, please refer to: https://github.com/PaddlePaddle/Paddle/wiki/Gradient-Check-Is-Required-for-Op-Test. The corresponding lines are as follows:\n${ERROR_LINES}\n"
        check_approval 1 26615455 6836917 43953930
    fi
fi

231 232
if [ -n "${echo_list}" ];then
  echo "****************"
233
  echo -e "${echo_list[@]}"
234 235
  echo "There are ${failed_num} approved errors."
  echo "****************"
Z
Zeng Jinle 已提交
236 237 238
fi

python ${PADDLE_ROOT}/tools/diff_api.py ${PADDLE_ROOT}/paddle/fluid/API_DEV.spec  ${PADDLE_ROOT}/paddle/fluid/API_PR.spec
239
python ${PADDLE_ROOT}/tools/check_op_register_type.py ${PADDLE_ROOT}/paddle/fluid/OP_TYPE_DEV.spec  ${PADDLE_ROOT}/paddle/fluid/OP_TYPE_PR.spec
Z
Zeng Jinle 已提交
240
if [ -n "${echo_list}" ]; then
241 242
  exit 1
fi