Update template to allow handlers to more cleanly handle encodings (ht: nex3)

actionpack/lib/action_view/template.rb

@@ -22,6 +22,10 @@ class Template
     # users will see diamonds with question marks in them in
     # the browser.
     #
+    # For the rest of this documentation, when we say "UTF-8",
+    # we mean "UTF-8 or whatever the default_internal encoding
+    # is set to". By default, it will be UTF-8.
+    #
     # To mitigate this problem, we use a few strategies:
     # 1. If the source is not valid UTF-8, we raise an exception
     #    when the template is compiled to alert the user
@@ -32,8 +36,7 @@ class Template
     #    to the resulting compiled source returned by the
     #    template handler.
     # 3. In all cases, we transcode the resulting String to
-    #    the <tt>default_internal</tt> encoding (which defaults
-    #    to UTF-8).
+    #    the UTF-8.
     #
     # This means that other parts of Rails can always assume
     # that templates are encoded in UTF-8, even if the original
@@ -60,14 +63,14 @@ class Template
     #
     # If you want to provide an alternate mechanism for
     # specifying encodings (like ERB does via <%# encoding: ... %>),
-    # you may indicate that you are willing to accept
-    # BINARY data by implementing <tt>self.accepts_binary?</tt>
+    # you may indicate that you will handle encodings yourself
+    # by implementing <tt>self.handles_encoding?</tt>
     # on your handler.
     #
-    # If you do, Rails will not raise an exception if
-    # the template's encoding could not be determined,
-    # assuming that you have another mechanism for
-    # making the determination.
+    # If you do, Rails will not try to encode the String
+    # into the default_internal, passing you the unaltered
+    # bytes tagged with the assumed encoding (from
+    # default_external).
     #
     # In this case, make sure you return a String from
     # your handler encoded in the default_internal. Since
@@ -171,7 +174,12 @@ def inspect
       # before passing the source on to the template engine, leaving a
       # blank line in its stead.
       #
-      # Note that after we figure out the correct encoding, we then
+      # If the template engine handles encodings, we send the encoded
+      # String to the engine without further processing. This allows
+      # the template engine to support additional mechanisms for
+      # specifying the encoding. For instance, ERB supports <%# encoding: %>
+      #
+      # Otherwise, after we figure out the correct encoding, we then
       # encode the source into Encoding.default_internal. In general,
       # this means that templates will be UTF-8 inside of Rails,
       # regardless of the original source encoding.
@@ -182,8 +190,11 @@ def compile(locals, view, mod)
         locals_code = locals.keys.map! { |key| "#{key} = local_assigns[:#{key}];" }.join
 
         if source.encoding_aware?
+          # Look for # encoding: *. If we find one, we'll encode the
+          # String in that encoding, otherwise, we'll use the
+          # default external encoding.
           if source.sub!(/\A#{ENCODING_FLAG}/, '')
-            encoding = $1
+            encoding = magic_encoding = $1
           else
             encoding = Encoding.default_external
           end
@@ -192,34 +203,28 @@ def compile(locals, view, mod)
           # or the encoding specified in the file
           source.force_encoding(encoding)
 
-          # If the original encoding is BINARY, the actual
-          # encoding is either stored out-of-band (such as
-          # in ERB <%# %> style magic comments) or missing.
-          # This is also true if the original encoding is
-          # something other than BINARY, but it's invalid.
-          if source.encoding != Encoding::BINARY && source.valid_encoding?
+          # If the user didn't specify an encoding, and the handler
+          # handles encodings, we simply pass the String as is to
+          # the handler (with the default_external tag)
+          if !magic_encoding && @handler.respond_to?(:handles_encoding?) && @handler.handles_encoding?
+            source
+          # Otherwise, if the String is valid in the encoding,
+          # encode immediately to default_internal. This means
+          # that if a handler doesn't handle encodings, it will
+          # always get Strings in the default_internal
+          elsif source.valid_encoding?
             source.encode!
-          # If the assumed encoding is incorrect, check to
-          # see whether the handler accepts BINARY. If it
-          # does, it has another mechanism for determining
-          # the true encoding of the String.
-          elsif @handler.respond_to?(:accepts_binary?) && @handler.accepts_binary?
-            source.force_encoding(Encoding::BINARY)
-          # If the handler does not accept BINARY, the
-          # assumed encoding (either the default_external,
-          # or the explicit encoding specified by the user)
-          # is incorrect. We raise an exception here.
+          # Otherwise, since the String is invalid in the encoding
+          # specified, raise an exception
           else
             raise WrongEncodingError.new(source, encoding)
           end
-
-          # Don't validate the encoding yet -- the handler
-          # may treat the String as raw bytes and extract
-          # the encoding some other way
         end
 
         code = @handler.call(self)
 
+        # Make sure that the resulting String to be evalled is in the
+        # encoding of the code
         source = <<-end_src
           def #{method_name}(local_assigns)
             _old_virtual_path, @_virtual_path = @_virtual_path, #{@virtual_path.inspect};_old_output_buffer = @output_buffer;#{locals_code};#{code}
@@ -229,20 +234,16 @@ def #{method_name}(local_assigns)
         end_src
 
         if source.encoding_aware?
-          # Handlers should return their source Strings in either the
-          # default_internal or BINARY. If the handler returns a BINARY
-          # String, we assume its encoding is the one we determined
-          # earlier, and encode the resulting source in the default_internal.
-          if source.encoding == Encoding::BINARY
-            source.force_encoding(Encoding.default_internal)
-          end
+          # Make sure the source is in the encoding of the returned code
+          source.force_encoding(code.encoding)
 
           # In case we get back a String from a handler that is not in
           # BINARY or the default_internal, encode it to the default_internal
           source.encode!
 
           # Now, validate that the source we got back from the template
-          # handler is valid in the default_internal
+          # handler is valid in the default_internal. This is for handlers
+          # that handle encoding but screw up
           unless source.valid_encoding?
             raise WrongEncodingError.new(@source, Encoding.default_internal)
           end

actionpack/lib/action_view/template/error.rb

@@ -13,6 +13,7 @@ def initialize(string, encoding)
     end
 
     def message
+      @string.force_encoding("BINARY")
       "Your template was not saved as valid #{@encoding}. Please " \
       "either specify #{@encoding} as the encoding for your template " \
       "in your text editor, or mark the template with its " \

actionpack/lib/action_view/template/handlers/erb.rb

@@ -79,51 +79,49 @@ class ERB < Handler
 
         ENCODING_TAG = Regexp.new("\\A(<%#{ENCODING_FLAG}-?%>)[ \\t]*")
 
-        def self.accepts_binary?
+        def self.handles_encoding?
           true
         end
 
         def compile(template)
           if template.source.encoding_aware?
-            # Even though Rails has given us a String tagged with the
-            # default_internal encoding (likely UTF-8), it is possible
-            # that the String is actually encoded using a different
-            # encoding, specified via an ERB magic comment. If the
-            # String is not actually UTF-8, the regular expression
-            # engine will (correctly) raise an exception. For now,
-            # we'll reset the String to BINARY so we can run regular
-            # expressions against it
+            # First, convert to BINARY, so in case the encoding is
+            # wrong, we can still find an encoding tag
+            # (<%# encoding %>) inside the String using a regular
+            # expression
             template_source = template.source.dup.force_encoding("BINARY")
 
-            # Erubis does not have direct support for encodings.
-            # As a result, we will extract the ERB-style magic
-            # comment, give the String to Erubis as BINARY data,
-            # and then tag the resulting String with the extracted
-            # encoding later
             erb = template_source.gsub(ENCODING_TAG, '')
             encoding = $2
 
-            if !encoding && (template.source.encoding == Encoding::BINARY)
-              raise WrongEncodingError.new(template_source, Encoding.default_external)
-            end
+            erb.force_encoding valid_encoding(template.source.dup, encoding)
+
+            # Always make sure we return a String in the default_internal
+            erb.encode!
           else
             erb = template.source.dup
           end
 
-          result = self.class.erb_implementation.new(
+          self.class.erb_implementation.new(
             erb,
             :trim => (self.class.erb_trim_mode == "-")
           ).src
+        end
+
+      private
+        def valid_encoding(string, encoding)
+          # If a magic encoding comment was found, tag the
+          # String with this encoding. This is for a case
+          # where the original String was assumed to be,
+          # for instance, UTF-8, but a magic comment
+          # proved otherwise
+          string.force_encoding(encoding) if encoding
+
+          # If the String is valid, return the encoding we found
+          return string.encoding if string.valid_encoding?
 
-          # If an encoding tag was found, tag the String
-          # we're returning with that encoding. Otherwise,
-          # return a BINARY String, which is what ERB
-          # returns. Note that if a magic comment was
-          # not specified, we will return the data to
-          # Rails as BINARY, which will then use its
-          # own encoding logic to create a UTF-8 String.
-          result = "\n#{result}".force_encoding(encoding).encode if encoding
-          result
+          # Otherwise, raise an exception
+          raise WrongEncodingError.new(string, string.encoding)
         end
       end
     end

actionpack/test/template/template_test.rb

@@ -114,11 +114,13 @@ def test_lying_with_magic_comment
     end
 
     def test_encoding_can_be_specified_with_magic_comment_in_erb
+      with_external_encoding Encoding::UTF_8 do
         @template = new_template("<%# encoding: ISO-8859-1 %>hello \xFCmlat")
         result = render
         assert_equal Encoding::UTF_8, render.encoding
         assert_equal "hello \u{fc}mlat", render
       end
+    end
 
     def test_error_when_template_isnt_valid_utf8
       assert_raises(ActionView::Template::Error, /\xFC/) do
@@ -126,5 +128,12 @@ def test_error_when_template_isnt_valid_utf8
         render
       end
     end
+
+    def with_external_encoding(encoding)
+      old, Encoding.default_external = Encoding.default_external, encoding
+      yield
+    ensure
+      Encoding.default_external = old
+    end
   end
 end
\ No newline at end of file