6964479: widen normalization of small int and long values should be symmetric

Summary: normalize widen value in xmeet() and xdual() methods for types Int and Long so the type meet will be symmetric.
Reviewed-by: jrose

src/share/vm/opto/type.cpp

@@ -182,6 +182,8 @@ int Type::uhash( const Type *const t ) {
   return t->hash();
 }
 
+#define SMALLINT ((juint)3)  // a value too insignificant to consider widening
+
 //--------------------------Initialize_shared----------------------------------
 void Type::Initialize_shared(Compile* current) {
   // This method does not need to be locked because the first system
@@ -240,6 +242,7 @@ void Type::Initialize_shared(Compile* current) {
   assert( TypeInt::CC_GT == TypeInt::ONE,     "types must match for CmpL to work" );
   assert( TypeInt::CC_EQ == TypeInt::ZERO,    "types must match for CmpL to work" );
   assert( TypeInt::CC_GE == TypeInt::BOOL,    "types must match for CmpL to work" );
+  assert( (juint)(TypeInt::CC->_hi - TypeInt::CC->_lo) <= SMALLINT, "CC is truly small");
 
   TypeLong::MINUS_1 = TypeLong::make(-1);        // -1
   TypeLong::ZERO    = TypeLong::make( 0);        //  0
@@ -1054,16 +1057,21 @@ const TypeInt *TypeInt::make( jint lo ) {
   return (TypeInt*)(new TypeInt(lo,lo,WidenMin))->hashcons();
 }
 
-#define SMALLINT ((juint)3)  // a value too insignificant to consider widening
-
-const TypeInt *TypeInt::make( jint lo, jint hi, int w ) {
+static int normalize_int_widen( jint lo, jint hi, int w ) {
   // Certain normalizations keep us sane when comparing types.
   // The 'SMALLINT' covers constants and also CC and its relatives.
-  assert(CC == NULL || (juint)(CC->_hi - CC->_lo) <= SMALLINT, "CC is truly small");
   if (lo <= hi) {
     if ((juint)(hi - lo) <= SMALLINT)  w = Type::WidenMin;
-    if ((juint)(hi - lo) >= max_juint)  w = Type::WidenMax; // plain int
+    if ((juint)(hi - lo) >= max_juint) w = Type::WidenMax; // TypeInt::INT
+  } else {
+    if ((juint)(lo - hi) <= SMALLINT)  w = Type::WidenMin;
+    if ((juint)(lo - hi) >= max_juint) w = Type::WidenMin; // dual TypeInt::INT
   }
+  return w;
+}
+
+const TypeInt *TypeInt::make( jint lo, jint hi, int w ) {
+  w = normalize_int_widen(lo, hi, w);
   return (TypeInt*)(new TypeInt(lo,hi,w))->hashcons();
 }
 
@@ -1103,14 +1111,14 @@ const Type *TypeInt::xmeet( const Type *t ) const {
 
   // Expand covered set
   const TypeInt *r = t->is_int();
-  // (Avoid TypeInt::make, to avoid the argument normalizations it enforces.)
-  return (new TypeInt( MIN2(_lo,r->_lo), MAX2(_hi,r->_hi), MAX2(_widen,r->_widen) ))->hashcons();
+  return make( MIN2(_lo,r->_lo), MAX2(_hi,r->_hi), MAX2(_widen,r->_widen) );
 }
 
 //------------------------------xdual------------------------------------------
 // Dual: reverse hi & lo; flip widen
 const Type *TypeInt::xdual() const {
-  return new TypeInt(_hi,_lo,WidenMax-_widen);
+  int w = normalize_int_widen(_hi,_lo, WidenMax-_widen);
+  return new TypeInt(_hi,_lo,w);
 }
 
 //------------------------------widen------------------------------------------
@@ -1202,7 +1210,7 @@ const Type *TypeInt::narrow( const Type *old ) const {
 //-----------------------------filter------------------------------------------
 const Type *TypeInt::filter( const Type *kills ) const {
   const TypeInt* ft = join(kills)->isa_int();
-  if (ft == NULL || ft->_lo > ft->_hi)
+  if (ft == NULL || ft->empty())
     return Type::TOP;           // Canonical empty value
   if (ft->_widen < this->_widen) {
     // Do not allow the value of kill->_widen to affect the outcome.
@@ -1304,13 +1312,21 @@ const TypeLong *TypeLong::make( jlong lo ) {
   return (TypeLong*)(new TypeLong(lo,lo,WidenMin))->hashcons();
 }
 
-const TypeLong *TypeLong::make( jlong lo, jlong hi, int w ) {
+static int normalize_long_widen( jlong lo, jlong hi, int w ) {
   // Certain normalizations keep us sane when comparing types.
-  // The '1' covers constants.
+  // The 'SMALLINT' covers constants.
   if (lo <= hi) {
     if ((julong)(hi - lo) <= SMALLINT)   w = Type::WidenMin;
-    if ((julong)(hi - lo) >= max_julong)  w = Type::WidenMax; // plain long
+    if ((julong)(hi - lo) >= max_julong) w = Type::WidenMax; // TypeLong::LONG
+  } else {
+    if ((julong)(lo - hi) <= SMALLINT)   w = Type::WidenMin;
+    if ((julong)(lo - hi) >= max_julong) w = Type::WidenMin; // dual TypeLong::LONG
   }
+  return w;
+}
+
+const TypeLong *TypeLong::make( jlong lo, jlong hi, int w ) {
+  w = normalize_long_widen(lo, hi, w);
   return (TypeLong*)(new TypeLong(lo,hi,w))->hashcons();
 }
 
@@ -1351,14 +1367,14 @@ const Type *TypeLong::xmeet( const Type *t ) const {
 
   // Expand covered set
   const TypeLong *r = t->is_long(); // Turn into a TypeLong
-  // (Avoid TypeLong::make, to avoid the argument normalizations it enforces.)
-  return (new TypeLong( MIN2(_lo,r->_lo), MAX2(_hi,r->_hi), MAX2(_widen,r->_widen) ))->hashcons();
+  return make( MIN2(_lo,r->_lo), MAX2(_hi,r->_hi), MAX2(_widen,r->_widen) );
 }
 
 //------------------------------xdual------------------------------------------
 // Dual: reverse hi & lo; flip widen
 const Type *TypeLong::xdual() const {
-  return new TypeLong(_hi,_lo,WidenMax-_widen);
+  int w = normalize_long_widen(_hi,_lo, WidenMax-_widen);
+  return new TypeLong(_hi,_lo,w);
 }
 
 //------------------------------widen------------------------------------------
@@ -1453,7 +1469,7 @@ const Type *TypeLong::narrow( const Type *old ) const {
 //-----------------------------filter------------------------------------------
 const Type *TypeLong::filter( const Type *kills ) const {
   const TypeLong* ft = join(kills)->isa_long();
-  if (ft == NULL || ft->_lo > ft->_hi)
+  if (ft == NULL || ft->empty())
     return Type::TOP;           // Canonical empty value
   if (ft->_widen < this->_widen) {
     // Do not allow the value of kill->_widen to affect the outcome.